World of Politics: Páidí’s prophecy may also apply to Galway


Watching Westmeath beat Dublin in the Leinster final on Sunday, I was reminded of an old Irish-language saying: An rud is annamh is iontach — that which is most rare is most wonderful.
The last time Westmeath won a Leinster final was 26 years ago, when the irrepressible late Páidí Ó Sé was manager. That was, remarkably, their first-ever Leinster championship victory. During that campaign, Ó Sé made his famous speech in which he told his players that a grain of rice could make all the difference in shifting the balance.
We may see something similar in Galway West this weekend. We could witness the first Independent Ireland candidate to win a bye-election. It might be the first African-born person elected to the Dáil. It could be a first bye-election victory in Galway West for the Social Democrats with a candidate little known beforehand. It could also be Sinn Féin’s first bye-election victory since Pearse Doherty’s breakthrough 16 years ago. Or it could be a government candidate bucking more than four decades of history by winning a seat usually reserved for the opposition
The issues in Galway West this time have been fascinating. If you had come to the constituency a year or two ago, especially in the city, people would have been talking almost exclusively about two things: traffic and housing.
The traffic situation remains chronic in Galway, particularly on the outskirts of the city, but some of the heat has gone out of the issue following the announcement of the ring road.
The ring road alone will not solve Galway’s traffic problems. The city will need a long-term, multifaceted and joined-up transport strategy. Yes, that includes bus lanes and bicycle lanes. It may eventually include some form of light rail.
In time, it will also mean more regular bus services to outlying areas of the county — enough, perhaps, to allow some people to rely a little less on their cars. But the reality is that in rural Ireland, cars will always remain part and parcel of everyday life.
The biggest emerging issue in Galway West — and perhaps in the bye-election as a whole — has been the cost of living. It manifested itself differently in the city and the county.
Housing, meanwhile, remains a huge issue. Prices in the city are astronomical and demand far outstrips supply across the county. Young people who want to buy their own homes are confronted by daunting obstacles in the form of deposits and mortgages that are, in many cases, simply impossible.
The biggest emerging issue in Galway West — and perhaps in the bye-election as a whole — has been the cost of living. It manifested itself differently in the city and the county.
In the city, people talked about electricity bills, grocery bills and the rising cost of goods and services. In the county, those concerns were there too, but because many families outside the city are heavily reliant on cars and undertake long journeys every day, the price of diesel and petrol is critical. The cost of home heating oil is also a major issue, particularly because much of Galway lacks access to natural gas or alternative energy sources.
For some voters, immigration will be a decisive issue, though I suspect they remain a minority. However, it may influence transfer patterns. I would be surprised if centre-left voters transferred in large numbers to one or two independent or smaller-party candidates who have taken particularpositions against accommodation centres for asylum seekers.
Another issue that has unexpectedly come to the fore has been the Irish language. Perhaps a little unfairly, it has affected Mark Lohan of Sinn Féin more than other candidates.
Only two of the 17 candidates — Seán Kyne and Míde Nic Fhionnlaoich — are fluent Irish speakers, so the pile-on directed at Lohan has been somewhat excessive. Certainly, he does not have much Irish, but like most of the other candidates, he has nothing against the language and is positive about Irish speakers and Gaeltacht communities.
Still, there was a certain undercurrent of negativity about his lack of Irish in the Gaeltacht regions of Connemara, and that may prove to be the grain of rice that tips the balance against him.
Bye-elections are always lotteries and notoriously difficult to predict. The bookmakers still have Noel Thomas slightly ahead of Kyne, and who are we to argue with the odds?
But I do not see it as a foregone conclusion. I think Kyne will come close. I also think one of the left-wing candidates could get very close indeed. The question is which one.
It is the same question we have been asking since the beginning of the campaign: will it be Helen Ogbu, will it be Míde Nic Fhionnlaoich, or will it be Mark Lohan?
I do not think the “vote left, transfer left” strategy has proven as strong as some expected. As the campaign developed, every party increasingly fought its own corner. There will be transfers within the left, but the question is whether they will reach a critical mass capable of determining the outcome?
It would certainly be a major surprise if Kyne were to win. There is a long tradition of government candidates losing bye-elections, but statistics exist only to be broken, and perhaps this weekend will prove the exception.
Looking at the two bye-elections as a whole, several outcomes remain possible. Sinn Féin and the Social Democrats could each win one or even two seats. Labour could win one. Independent Ireland could take Galway West.
But perhaps the biggest twist of all would be if Fine Gael won a seat — not the one vacated by Paschal Donohoe in Dublin Central, but the left-leaning seat vacated by Catherine Connolly in Galway West.
Like all the other scenarios, though, it is impossible to say with certainty whether or not that will be the outcome. An rud is annamh is iontach.
Harry McGee is political correspondent of the Irish Times.
