World of Politics: Can Kyne buck the old  trend on bye-elections?

placeholder image
Back in the chase...Cllr Thomas Welby and Senator Sean Kyne, with Cllr Terry O’Flaherty between them, at the Galway West count last time out. Photo: Brian Harding.

Well, this is one for the history books; could Sean Kyne buck the trend of government candidates not winning bye-elections? For over 30 years now, the hard-and-fast rule has been that government parties do not win bye-elections unless there are exceptional circumstances.

Only three by-elections have been won by government candidates since 1982. Two of them — Helen McEntee and Gabrielle McFadden of Fine Gael — came after close relatives of theirs passed away while in office.

The third was won by the Labour Party in Dublin West in 2011, and that only occurred because Brian Lenihan Jr died within weeks of the general election result. Labour, brand new to government and still riding a wave of popularity, saw Patrick Nulty easily win that bye-election.

That was also a good demonstration of how quickly the tide can turn. Patrick Nulty himself resigned three years later and, by then, Labour had become electorally toxic. The party finished a distant loser in the resulting by-election.

So, if you follow the history of Irish bye-elections, Sean Kyne should have no expectation of winning. Yet there he was in the Irish Times/TG4 poll last week, leading the field on 17%, narrowly ahead of Independent Ireland candidate Noel Thomas.

Labour candidate Helen Ogbu was on 12%, and if the findings of this poll are correct, it is she who will lead the left-wing challenge.

It was a very bad poll for Sinn Féin and Fianna Fáil. On these figures, neither Fianna Fáil candidate Cillian nor Sinn Féin candidate Mark Lohan look likely to challenge for the seat.

Lohan’s result was just 7%, and unless things change radically in the next fortnight, he will not be in contention. Sinn Féin is the main opposition party and Mairéad Farrell topped the poll here in 2024. Of all parties, it should be expecting to win here.

Keane is a new and very young candidate from the east of the city. His showing of 8% is less than half of Fianna Fáil’s vote in the general election, and he will need to improve significantly if he is to have any chance of making this anything other than a bad day for the party.

Now, the results of the poll need to be taken with a very large grain of salt. The sample size was small — only 400 people — leaving a margin of error of over 4%, meaning there could be major variances in the actual figures.

Still, it appears Kyne is doing better than Thomas on transfers.

Thomas’s 16% is a strong showing, but because of his stance on immigration and his prominence as a fuel protester, he will not be everyone’s cup of tea.

He cannot rely on transfers in the same way that opposition or independent candidates often can in bye-elections.

Paradoxically, Kyne could end up doing better than Thomas on transfers. That said, 17% is not an earth-shattering number. Kyne will need a considerable boost in first preferences if he is to keep other candidates at bay.

On these figures, it very much looks like Helen Ogbu — currently 3% ahead of the promising Social Democrats candidate Míde Nic Fhionnlaoich — could emerge as the key left-wing challenger.

Ogbu would likely take a huge swathe of left-wing transfers if she stays ahead and could also pick up transfers from the centrist candidate Mike Cubbard, who has done comparatively well on 7%.

Ironically, Kyne may need Thomas’s transfers if he stays ahead of him, in much the same way that Thomas would need Kyne’s transfers if he is to have any hope of winning. Both will also be relying on transfers from Oughterard Independent Tom Welby.

If it were to come down to a straight contest between Kyne and Thomas, Kyne would probably be the more transfer-friendly candidate, although it is hard to see huge numbers of left-wing votes flowing in his direction.

That could make him a marginal favourite if he remains ahead of Thomas.

We have seen constituency polls before that were completely contradicted by election results.

Maybe this poll reflected the reality at the moment it was taken, or maybe it overstated the performance of one or two candidates. There is no doubt that it is still all to play for.

But the one thing the poll may have done is provide the first indication of momentum in this bye-election. The fact that Kyne, a government candidate, is performing so strongly is genuinely surprising.

Thomas has been regarded as the front-runner since the by-election was announced, and he will need a very strong first-preference vote if he is to take the seat.

The left-wing movement will depend heavily on transfers, but for that to happen, the leading left candidate would need considerably more first preferences than Ogbu currently has — and that is far from guaranteed.

It is an unusual constituency. At its centre is one of the state’s biggest cities, but it also contains vast rural areas, each with different political dynamics.

The successful candidate was always likely to be someone capable of straddling both environments — someone who could win votes in the city while also connecting with voters in the outlying rural areas.

Kyne is a vastly experienced politician with strong name recognition across the constituency. Perhaps we should not be entirely surprised that he is performing so well at this stage of the campaign.

There is still a lot to play for, and yes, it is still far too early to start rewriting the history books — or the iron law that insists government parties rarely win bye-elections.

Harry McGee is the political correspondent of the Irish Times.

Powered by
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice