A Different View: Beating Scott Hastings on BBC Radio Scotland


The death over the weekend of former Scottish and Lions rugby star Scott Hastings at the age of just 61 sent shock waves through the sporting world, even if it had been known that the tartan warrior had been battling cancer for some time.
But, with apologies for doing that thing that too many people do when famous sportsmen die and they make it all about themselves, the passing of Scott Hastings brought back memories of my one and only international triumph in what is, by coincidence, my own 61 years to date.
Because back in the nineties, I occasionally appeared on BBC Radio Scotland, on Gary Robertson’s mid-morning show, which was a mix between current affairs and Gerry Ryan, if that adds up.
Occasionally I’d be on to offer a view on Irish politics, not because I was an expert or anything of the sort but because I was then with the Star newspaper and we didn’t start work until 2pm – so I was always available to drop into the small BBC radio studio on Grafton Street in the mornings.
And like a lot of media contact lists, once you were on it, it could be difficult to get off it – hence when an Irish voice was needed, you were paraded out for items that you knew little or nothing about.
Once in a while it was a bit of craic – as it was on the morning that I took on Scott Hastings.
This was on foot of some ‘survey’ to pick the sexiest accent in this part of the world – so Gary decided to carry out his own study by inviting on an Irishman, an Englishman and a Scotsman, as well as a Frenchman and a Welshman just to give this a more international feel.
And the end game was to decide which of the accents from these parts was the sexiest.
The English, French and Welsh representatives were as anonymous as I was and am, but Scotland – anxious to secure a home win – put up their international rugby centre.
Even if you ignored his 65 international rugby caps over eleven seasons – making him for a while Scotland’s most capped player ever – as well as his physique and his celebrity status, Scott should have been a shoo-in for success, given that he also boasted a voice that made Sean Connery sound like he’d been sucking on helium balloons.
But I’d hardly be telling the story if this ran true to form, and by the time the ladies of Scotland – because this unscientific phone poll was only for women – the Frenchman had followed the English man and the Welsh man into the proverbial bin.
Needless to say – because this was Scotland – the English man was always going to be first out, but you’d have only got short odds on this being anything other than a fight between Scott the Scot and the Frenchman.
To compound the odds against me, I’d been out the night before and was therefore an octave or two lower than the norm – a bit like Tom Waits chewing sandpaper, sounding like he was staring in a Tom Cruise movie about Irish emigrants in Oklahoma.
That, in case you missed the nineties, was the plot of Far and Away – mainly remembered for having the worst Irish accents on screen since Darby O’Gill was chatting away with the Little People way back in 1959.
Anyway, we were down to two in the running on BBC Radio and like an unseeded player at Wimbledon I was both delighted to have made it this far and relieved that it would soon be over so that I might go back to bed.
Except the ladies of Scotland voted for me – and I hasten to add that, before I’d lose the run of myself, this was based on voice alone. They’d be well familiar with Scott Hastings’ image, but they’d clearly never seen a picture of me.
All of that was just a bit of fun of course and in the way that it gave me nothing more than a story to dine out on, it hardly derailed Scott’s progress, nor did it damage his status as a Scottish rugby legend.
It didn’t dent his confidence on his accent either because right up to his death, he had carved out a stellar career as a rugby analyst – most notably with ITV Sport – and by all accounts he was as decent off the pitch as he was deadly on it.
The younger brother of fellow international and Lion Gavin – the first brothers to line out on the same Test Lions team since the early 1900s – he died on what would have been his late wife Jenny’s birthday. She had died by suicide less than two years ago.
And that’s not breaking any omerta because, true to form, Scott Hastings spoke about depression and wanted the world to know of their good times – so that her death, and its manner, would not define her in anyone’s eyes.
He himself had been in remission from his cancer before it came back – so clearly life had dealt him tough blows. And yet the stories this week were of a character – on and off the pitch.
BBC Scotland’s chief sportswriter, Limerickman Tom English, wrote this week of a Scottish tour of New Zealand stopping off in Invercargill where the normal mundanity was broken up by Scott’s standing on a chair in a pub conducting the assembled mass in what might euphemistically be described as a rousing version of the Proclaimers’ 500 Miles.
To quote Tom, Scott Hastings was ‘a force of energy and positivity, in his rugby career and after his rugby career, in happy family times and in days that were profoundly sad, in his work and his charity work’. Despite his own cancer battle, he devoted much of his time to working with the charity set up in memory of his great friend and team-mate Doddie Weir, who also died way too young, from MND.
He showed character in victory and defeat on and off the field of play and his passing this week was rightly mourned by rugby fans and the world alike.
And I remembered the day my voice beat his in a contest of no consequence, reflecting again that, between us, we had a combined total of 65 Scottish caps.

