Bound and gagged publican died from severe beating


Date Published: 15-Nov-2012
By Ann Healy
Oughterard publican and schoolteacher John Kenny whose badly beaten body was found tied up and gagged on the toilet floor of his pub last year, died as a result of blunt force trauma to his upper body and from asphyxia or suffocation.
The asphyxia was probably caused by the position in which his body was found face down on the ground with a jacket tied tightly around his face, a jury at Galway Circuit Criminal Court was told yesterday.
State Pathologist, Professor Marie Cassidy was giving evidence on the third day of the trial of former Galway bus depot security guard and Romanian national, Florin Fitzpatrick(38), who denies a charge of withholding information from Gardai during the ensuing investigation into Mr Kenny’s death, which occurred on September 25 last year at his pub on Main Street, Oughterard.
Dr. Cassidy said she carried out a post mortem on Mr Kenny’s body, whose hands had been tied tightly behind his back with the cable from a set of fairy lights.
She gave detailed evidence of the extensive bruising she found on the upper body, both at the back and on the chest. Several ribs, both back and front had been fractured as had his breast bone. This, she said, was a significant finding, as it suggested a crush injury to his chest.
Cartilage around his Adman’s apple had been fractured also, she said, in a manner consistent with a blow to the neck. There were also defensive injuries to the arms.
Professor Cassidy said she noted parallel scratch marks along the left side of the body, consistent with it being dragged along the ground.
Mr Kenny’s trousers were down around his knees and his underpants were just below the buttocks. She said there was no evidence of a sexual assault and the position of the clothing was again consistent with the body being dragged along the ground.
“These injuries to the trunk suggest there were heavy blows to the back and ones to the chest with a large object. Considerable force had to be used to inflict these injuries, given the pattern of trauma,” she explained to the jury.
A contributing factor to Mr Kenny’s death, she said, could have been ‘positional asphyxia, due to the position in which the body was found face down.
“He had been left lying in a face down position with his hands tied behind his back. That could have caused positional asphyxia – a form of suffocation,” she said.
The trial is continuing before Judge Gerard Griffin and a jury of six men and six women.
For more on this story, see the Galway City Tribune.
