World of Politics: By-election runners are leaving the parade ring

placeholder image
Social Democrats leader Holly Cairns and by-election candidate Míde Nic Fhionnlaoichat chat to Lisa King of Galway Bay Soaps at the Galway Market.

The selection by Fianna Fáil of the young councillor, Cillian Keane, as its candidate for the Galway West by-election was the final act of the prelude – and he will already know that one of the great realities of Irish politics is that it is very unusual for a government party to win a by-election.

There was a period of over 30 years when that held utterly true – from Noel Treacy’s victory in Galway East in 1982 until Patrick Nulty won a seat for the Labour Party in 2011, a few months after that party had gone into government.

Usually, by-election victories are reserved for opposition parties. Indeed, sometimes someone emerges from relative obscurity to snatch an unlikely victory.

So, you would think that neither Keane nor Fine Gael’s candidate, Senator Seán Kyne, will be in the final running.

The field does look more open than in many previous by-elections, so perhaps one or both of the government parties think they can buck the trend. However, based on past performance, that still seems unlikely.

The Fianna Fáil convention on Sunday night was a lively affair. It was crowded with delegates from across the constituency, and there were three very serious candidates, all of whom ran strong campaigns – Councillor Mairtín Lee from Connemara, Galway City councillor Alan Cheevers, and Keane himself.

He may be only 25 years of age and less than two years in elected office, but he appears to be the latest young Fianna Fáil councillor in County Galway who is a politician in a hurry.

By all accounts, he put in a very solid campaign, and a week beforehand many in Fianna Fáil people were saying to me he was the person to beat.

So, can he defy the odds? It is a good question. The strong convention turnout, the presence of multiple credible candidates, and the energy of the campaign will give the party some impetus. But it is a big ask—perhaps too big. Still, you never know.

From the outset, many have said that Noel Thomas is the candidate to beat. He was the last person eliminated in the general election in late 2024, having topped the poll in Connemara South in the local elections that June.

His profile was raised by the controversy surrounding protests against an accommodation centre at a hotel in Rosscahill, which was subsequently burned down by unknown perpetrators.

Thomas’s stance on the issue created significant controversy, and it is certain that questions about his position will arise throughout the campaign. He will certainly face far more scrutiny than he would in a general, or council, election.

Kyne has a high profile and is probably the strongest candidate Fine Gael could run, but it remains a tall order. To win, he would need to secure a large number of transfers—and, like Keane, he may struggle to do so.

Harry McGee

Kyne has a high profile and is probably the strongest candidate Fine Gael could run, but it remains a tall order. To win, he would need to secure a large number of transfers—and, like Keane, he may struggle to do so.

Some have mentioned Tom Welby as a potential outside contender. He is from Oughterard, close to the homes of Kyne and Thomas. Here you should see regional transfers come into play.

The question then arises – how will the left fare? This is, after all, Catherine Connolly’s seat. There are several candidates on the left, though none has a national profile. There is a vote left, stay left pact in place involving six of the candidates but will it have the same potency in a constituency that is as much rural as urban?

Perhaps Labour’s Helen Ogbu has the highest, but she will need to broaden her appeal beyond Galway city if she is to stay ahead of the others.

Sheila Garrity is an interesting candidate. A long-time supporter of Connolly and a senior figure in her Presidential campaign, she has been positioned by her supporters as the ‘Connolly candidate’.

However, as an independent without prior elected experience, she faces a significant challenge. She did get an early start, launching her campaign ahead of many others, which has given her some momentum.

Still, it may be difficult for her to get ahead of other left-wing candidates when transfers come into play.

Transfers will, in fact, be key for all left-wing candidates. In that context, the dark horse could be Míde Nic Fhionnlaoich of the Social Democrats, a native Irish speaker from Connemara.

The Social Democrats have been performing strongly in recent opinion polls and have been something of the “flavour of the month.”

Nic Fhionnlaoich could prove a surprise package in Galway West, though winning outright would be another matter.

Sinn Féin topped the poll in the November 2024 general election. Its candidate, Mark Lohan, should secure the highest number of first preferences among left-wing contenders.

Lohan should perform strongly, given the party’s position as the main opposition force, but Sinn Féin will need to focus on attracting more transfers from smaller left-wing parties.

These parties—including the Social Democrats and the Greens—are likely to transfer heavily among themselves. Despite the pact, there are two different sets of left-wing politicians vying against each other.

The Green Party’s candidate, former councillor Niall Murphy, is a capable politician, but it may be too soon for the party to recover from its heavy losses in the 2024 general election.

Mike Cubbard is another interesting figure: an independent and the current Mayor of Galway, with a strong local profile. Again like other city candidates, his challenge will be to broaden his appeal.

Galway West is an unusual constituency. It encompasses the city, the hinterland to the east, and the vast rural areas stretching west of the River Corrib into Connemara.

Any candidate hoping to win will need to be strong across all three regions. And that's what makes it so hard to predict.

Harry McGee is political correspondent of the Irish Times.

Powered by
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice