Named tenant refused to allow landlord into Galway home of 16 years because he was afraid 'some guys' would evict him


The tenant told a tribunal that he was not refusing access, but needed sufficient time to prepare
A tenant of 16 years who refused to allow his landlord access to the apartment because he was afraid “some guys would come and try to move [him] out” has been ordered to vacate the property.
Olgierd Frankowski moved into Apartment 1A at The Cobblestones on Eyre Street in April 2010, paying rent of €570 a month. The landlord claimed that this had increased to €689 but this was disputed by the tenant, who said he had not received a rent review notice.
A Residential Tenancies Board (RTB) tribunal heard that a dispute arose following the death of the landlord, Agnes Fleming, in December 2024, after which the executors of her estate, Michelle and Sharon Fleming, sought access to the property.
Requests were made five times, with Mr Frankowski requesting more notice, providing “vague timelines”, and saying he was not in a position to facilitate an inspection for health reasons.
Mr Frankowski told the tribunal that he was concerned if he allowed an inspection, that “some guys would come and try to move me out of the dwelling”. He insisted that he was not refusing access, but required sufficient time to prepare.
The tribunal heard that the landlord served a warning notice on February 27, 2025, seeking access within 10 days. When this period expired and access had not been granted, a notice of termination was issued on March 14.
Representatives for the landlord argued that Mr Frankowski had failed to propose alternative dates for access in his responses, while the tenant’s representative said sufficient notice had not been provided.
The tribunal found that the notice of termination had complied with all the requirements of the Residential Tenancies Act 2004 and was therefore valid. It said the tenant had breached Section 16(c) of the Act by failing to allow reasonable access for inspections.
It determined that the 10 days’ notice provided by the landlords had constituted a reasonable period. It said Mr Frankowski’s health concerns and stress did not excuse his total refusal to permit access or propose alternative arrangements.
In its decision, the tribunal said the notice terminating the tenancy had been valid, and Mr Frankowski had been overholding since April 2025. It ordered him to vacate and give up possession of the dwelling within 28 days.
It instructed the landlord to refund the security deposit of €570 upon gaining vacant possession, less any amounts lawfully deducted in accordance with the Act. Mr Frankowski should continue to pay rent until he vacates.
The tribunal noted that the amount of rent payable had not been agreed by the parties, but no application had been made for a determination in this regard. It therefore made no decision on this issue, but said this did not relieve either party of their obligations under the tenancy.
