Tenancy tribunal gives Galway grandmother 28 days to vacate home of 14 years


The landlord had been willing to grant some leeway regarding notice because he did not want to see her ‘out on the street’
A grandmother who has lived in a Galway property for nearly 14 years has been ordered to vacate within 28 days after a Residential Tenancies Board (RTB) tribunal found that she had been overholding since April 2025.
The tribunal upheld the validity of a notice of termination served on tenant Lucilla Bertani by her landlord, Jon McDonnell, who was seeking vacant possession of 8 Saint Bridget’s Place, Prospect Hill, so he can carry out works and move into the residence.
The tenancy originally commenced in June 2012 under the Rental Accommodation Scheme (RAS), with the rent set at €900 per month and an €800 deposit paid at the outset.
A notice of termination accompanied by a signed statutory declaration was served on the tenant on August 29, 2024, setting a termination date of April 10, 2025.
The notice had been signed by the landlord’s father Pat McDonnell, who originally owned the dwelling but has since passed away, leaving Jon McDonnell as the current landlord.
He referred the case to the RTB for a tribunal hearing after mediation between the parties failed.
At the hearing, Mr McDonnell stated that, while he was keen to secure possession of the dwelling, he was prepared to grant leeway on the termination date because he did not want to see the tenant out on the street.
He noted that Galway City Council, which administers the RAS scheme, had contacted him to say the tenant had turned down an offered property. Mr McDonnell added that the tenant’s daughter had given birth to a baby last December, and he believed the refusal may have been due to the lack of an extra bedroom.
A representative for Ms Bertani told the tribunal that they had never previously received a formal offer from Galway City Council, but now had one in place. They stated that the proposed property was nearly ready except for the flooring.
While they expected to receive keys within weeks, the representative said they could not move in until the works were finished because of dust affecting the baby, and they were unable to commit to a firm moving date.
In its findings, the three-person tribunal determined that the tenant held a Part 4 tenancy, which may be terminated under the Residential Tenancies Act 2004 where a landlord requires the property for their own occupation or for a family member.
The tribunal found that the notice of termination had satisfied all statutory requirements, having provided 224 days of notice. It noted that there was no dispute that the landlord required the dwelling for his own use.
Ruling that Ms Bertani has been overholding since April 2025, the tribunal ordered the tenant and all other occupants to give up possession and vacate within 28 days.
The tribunal also ordered the tenant to continue paying rent at €900 per month – or a daily rate of €29.58 – from the date of the hearing until the property is vacated. Mr McDonnell was directed to refund the full €800 security deposit upon receiving vacant possession, less any lawful deductions.
