Judge dismisses parking prosecutions due to glitch in law

Judge Alan Mitchellplaceholder image
Judge Alan Mitchell

Dozens of parking summonses have been either struck out or adjourned at Galway District Court due to a glitch in the legislation.

Judge Alan Mitchell gave lawyers for Galway City Council the opportunity to prove him wrong on this matter, but they were unable to do so.

“There is a potentially appalling vista, until this is rectified,” he said of this issue of legislation, which is badly affecting local councils when they attempt to prosecute.

The issue relates to pay-and-display prosecutions, brought before the court either because a person ‘over stayed their welcome’ or had no ticket displayed; this did not affect other types of parking fines, however, which went ahead as normal.

In cases where the defendant was in court, the Judge struck out their summons – although this does not stop the local authority from bringing a prosecution in the future. For those who were absent, their cases were adjourned to a date in April.

“What is important in the law is that there is some consistencies,” Judge Mitchell said.

The issue arose over the awarding of costs to the prosecutors, which the Judge said he does not allow unless there is a statutory provision for it.

Solicitor for Galway City Council, Edward Molloy, asked the Judge to reconsider.

“The court might take into account the considerable level of work involved, and the number of opportunities given to resolve the cases. It is a big effort to organise this on behalf of Galway City Council, ourselves, and the court services, to make sure it goes smoothly.”

The Judge acknowledged this, and said that while the District Court rules allowed for discretion, his view was that if it was not specifically provided for in Statute he would not award costs.

He requested a copy of the specific by-laws that the Council intended to rely on for the purpose of prosecution.

“They don’t comply with the law,” the Judge replied.

“It has to be proved under documentary evidence or printed by the Statutory office…. There is a fundamental difficulty by the Oireachtas passing the 2004 Act and having to prove under documentary evidence, which is providing difficulty for the City Council.”

Judge Mitchell allowed Mr Molloy and his colleague time to verify or dispute his point of view.

“On a previous occasion I struck-out all summonses, and I was judicially reviewed. I want to allow the City Council to engage with me that my understanding of the Road Traffic by-laws is correct. I will allow time to see if they can address this.

“When I saw the lacunae I checked, and it seems to be something that local authorities may be having difficulty with. If the law is as is, then it is not for me to award costs. I would rather not be judicially reviewed, as this would cause everything to grind to a halt.”

He explained the delay to the large number of people waiting for their cases to be heard that a previous court had struck-out all cases where the prosecution was unable to produce the relevant document they were relying on.

“The Court of Appeal, however, said that they should have been allowed time to produce it,” he said.

Mr Molloy was unable to satisfy the Judge in this regard, and he proceeded to go through the list of hundreds of names – adjourning the relevant cases of those who did not attend, and striking-out those who were there.

“They will be struck out today, but if the local authority decides or the High Court decides that I’m wrong, they may be re-issued,” Judge Mitchell said.

“This is definitely not the end of it. That’s a matter for the City Council and how it decides to deal with it.”

Powered by
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice