‘Devoid of ambition’ - Strong but mixed reactions as Budget 2027 is announced

Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers and Finance Minister Simon Harris with the Budget 2027placeholder image
Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers and Finance Minister Simon Harris with the Budget 2027 | PA

Minister for Finance Simon Harris and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers announced the Budget in the Dáil on Tuesday afternoon.

Galway Live’s Budget 2027 coverage is sponsored by Heneghan Financial Planning

Heneghan Financial Planningplaceholder image
Heneghan Financial Planning | Heneghan Financial Planning

Minister for Finance Simon Harris and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers both addressed the Dáil after 1pm and there has been a mixed reaction across the country to the multi-billion suite of measures they announced in Budget 2027.

Simon Harris said in his opening statement: “People need to feel the benefits of economic growth in their daily lives and in their pockets.”

Minister for Public Expenditure, Infrastructure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation, Jack Chambers claimed that success must be measured in the difference people can feel and see in their daily lives.

He said “The Budget I am announcing today represents a scale of investment in our public services and infrastructure not seen before in our State.”

Both ministers announced a range of measures to be introduced, including a 79 cent increase in minimum wage, a €1 tobacco tax hike and a personal income tax package worth 1.3 billion euros.

The opposition had heavy criticism for the budget.

Sinn Féin’s finance spokesperson Pearse Doherty slammed the budget, claiming that it’s an insult to call it a budget for workers and believes it’s leaving ordinary people behind.

He said: “It can be summed up in five simple words- gone before you get it.

“Families are handing over huge amounts of their income every single month in extortionate rents.

“That’s probably the biggest indictment of government’s failure in terms of policy … years of rent, years of saving, years of watching house prices climb faster and faster and faster, and their deposits still not there.

“Ordinary people deserve so, so much better than what you have delivered here today.”

Social Democrats TD Cian O’Callaghan claimed that Budget 2027 is ‘totally devoid of ambition’.

“It is lacking in any new ideas. It says to people who can’t pay their soaring energy bills, you are on your own because the help that was repeatedly promised has not materialised.

“Instead, what we got was tinkering around the edges, nothing substantive to address the key issue that households are facing: that electricity bills, which are already the highest in Europe, are continuing to skyrocket.”

Sinn Féin's Public Expenditure spokesperson Mairead Farrell said: “If this was a budget for workers, it would include extensive tax cuts for all workers."

Landlords have criticised the government for failing to address rental market concerns in the Budget.

Mary Conway, Chairperson of the Irish Property Owners Association (IPOA) said: “This Government has been warned repeatedly about what is happening in Ireland’s rental market, and Budget 2027 shows that it has chosen not to listen.

“You cannot claim to be tackling Ireland’s housing crisis while simultaneously pursuing policies that are driving landlords out of the rental market.

“Landlords are selling up, rental supply is under severe pressure, and yet Government has failed to provide measures needed to retain the people who are providing homes to hundreds of thousands of tenants.”

The National Women’s Council (NWC) welcomed a number of improvements for women in Budget 2027, including on childcare and contraception, but says long-term systemic reform is needed to solve the childcare crisis and address systemic inequalities of women.

NWC is disappointed at tax reforms, which will benefit men and other middle and high earners much more than women and other low earners.

Executive Director of NWC, Corrinne Hasson said: “NWC is disappointed that the Government has not committed €70 million to the Transport Authority of Ireland to maintain existing service provision and prevent public transport fare increases being introduced in 2027.

“Increased costs of public transport will hit groups dependant on public transport, and that are already struggling, harder, particularly lone parent headed households and students.”

Retailers have said the €1 tobacco tax hike in the Budget will drive customers away from local shops and into the black market.

Amárach polling commissioned by RAS before the Budget found that 43% would look outside the State for tobacco if prices increased again, compared with just 19% who would continue buying from Irish retailers.

This comes on top of more than half of tobacco consumers (55%) already buying some or all of their tobacco outside Ireland.

RAS says the government is penalising legitimate retailers already facing soaring business costs, while failing to tackle a booming illegal tobacco market and handing it to criminal gangs.

RAS National Spokesperson Benny Gilsenan said: “Retailers are already struggling with the soaring cost of running a business.

“Now we are being told to compete with people selling cigarettes for a fraction of the price, while the Government has failed to properly tackle the black market.

“They had all the figures in front of them. They chose to ignore the warning, and it is retailers, taxpayers and communities who will end up paying for it.”

Hauliers have welcomed Budget 2027 measures, but say outstanding issues remain.

Irish Road Haulage Association (IRHA) President, Ger Hyland, has today welcomed a number of measures set out in Budget 2027 that the IRHA had campaigned for.

Those measures include a continuation of the diesel rebate scheme until the end of 2026 with continued review, an extra two month payment to hauliers of the Road Transporters Support Scheme (RTSS) to be paid before Christmas, and a continuation of the fuel excise reductions into the Spring of 2027.

“These measures will help to keep prices at the supermarket down. It will also breathe some life into our industry, which simply cannot afford diesel prices at up to and over €2.20 a litre”

Hyland also criticised the government’s decision to not introduce targeted biofuel subsidies for the heavy goods vehicle sector in Budget 2027.

The IRHA had proposed two practical and targeted measures: a 12c per litre Biofuel Rebate Scheme for the sustainable component of blended diesel and a 24c per litre rebate for operators using 100% HVO as a diesel substitute.

Neither proposal was taken up in Budget 2027.

Retail Excellence Ireland (REI), the largest representative body for the retail industry in Ireland, has said that an expected increase of 79c in the minimum wage to €14.94 was a terrible move for business that showed how short-sighted and out of touch the Government is.

Commenting on Budget 2027, Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation General Secretary Phil Ní Sheaghdha said: “Nurses and midwives will be disappointed today that the Government’s focus when it comes to the health service appears to be on driving productivity, rather than addressing the root causes of long waiting times and overcrowding – insufficient staffing and capacity.

“The ESRI estimates that an additional 6,500 inpatient beds will be required by 2040. Against that backdrop, Budget 2027 remains silent on the amount of acute beds that will be delivered in 2027.”

Family Carers Ireland has said Budget 2027 falls short of what is needed to support family carers and fails to respond to the growing care challenge facing Ireland.

Sharon Foley, CEO of Family Carers Ireland, said: "While there are some welcome measures in today's package, many family carers will struggle to see how this Budget changes the reality of their everyday lives.

"For too many families, the pressures remain the same. Rising costs, inadequate services and little or no access to respite. This Budget asks family carers to continue carrying huge responsibility while offering too little in return."

With both strongly positive and negative reactions to Budget 2027, it looks set to split opinion across Ireland in the coming weeks.

Powered by
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice